Taoiseach Responds to Concerns Over Trade with Occupied Territories

Taoiseach Micheal Martin addressed concerns regarding the trade of services from the Occupied Palestinian Territories, stating that the volume of such imports is “not huge.” This response came amidst accusations of the government “slow walking” legislation intended to prohibit trade with illegal Israeli settlements. Critics have expressed fears that the forthcoming Occupied Territories Bill may focus solely on goods while excluding services.

During a session of Leaders’ Questions on October 25, 2023, Social Democrats leader Holly Cairns raised the issue, criticizing the potential omission of services from the proposed legislation. Although she acknowledged the recent release of hostages on both sides, she emphasized the ongoing dehumanization of Palestinians. Cairns pointed out that many of those released by Israel had not faced charges or convictions yet were still labeled as prisoners.

She remarked, “Even in this fragile peace, Palestinians continue to be dehumanised,” and highlighted the tragic reality that “five Gazans were murdered by Israeli forces yesterday morning, just two days after committing to a ceasefire.” Cairns criticized the actions of the Israeli government, stating that the violence and oppression faced by Palestinians have deep historical roots that extend beyond recent conflicts.

Cairns argued that Ireland has a duty under international law to cease all trade with illegal Israeli settlements. She warned that a significant portion of trade between Ireland and these settlements would persist if the bill does not include services.

In response, Micheal Martin acknowledged the uncertainty surrounding the volume of services imported from the Occupied Territories but maintained that it was likely not substantial. He noted the challenges in tracing services compared to goods, which can be documented more easily through certificates of origin. “No decision has been made in relation to services,” Martin stated, underlining the complexities involved in determining a “clear territorial link” in various sectors such as financial consulting and software development.

The Taoiseach emphasized that the primary concern for Gaza lies in ensuring the unobstructed delivery of humanitarian aid. He expressed hope for sustained peace in the region, indicating that efforts must focus on facilitating significant volumes of aid into Gaza.

Martin also described the release of hostages as a “big moment” and asserted that they should never have been taken in the first place. He called attention to the fact that many hostages were attending a music festival when abducted, reiterating that detaining Palestinians without trial or evidence is equally unacceptable.

As discussions continue regarding the Occupied Territories Bill, the complexities surrounding trade with illegal settlements and the humanitarian situation in Gaza remain pressing issues for the Irish government.