Nottingham Forest to File PGMOL Complaint After Tarkowski Incident

Nottingham Forest has announced plans to file a formal complaint to the Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) following a contentious incident involving Everton’s James Tarkowski during their match on December 6, 2025. Everton secured a decisive 3-0 victory at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, but Forest officials are particularly incensed by what they believe was a missed opportunity for a red card against Tarkowski.

The incident in question occurred in the 11th minute when Tarkowski engaged in a physical confrontation with Nottingham Forest forward Dan Ndoye. According to Forest’s management, Tarkowski’s actions constituted violent conduct, an assessment seemingly supported by their frustration over the lack of disciplinary action from both the on-field officials and the Video Assistant Referee (VAR).

Following the match, Forest officials expressed their anger, with a spokesperson stating they felt the incident warranted significant scrutiny due to its potential impact on the game’s outcome. Reports indicate that the club is seeking an explanation from the PGMOL regarding the decision not to penalize Tarkowski.

Dyche’s Reaction and the Match Context

Sean Dyche, the Everton manager, addressed the incident during his post-match comments, remarking on the unusual nature of the decision. He stated, “I’m amazed big Tarky got away with that.” Dyche’s remark underscores the confusion surrounding the officiating, especially given the match’s importance for Nottingham Forest, who are currently battling relegation. The defeat leaves them in 17th place in the Premier League, just above the relegation zone, with West Ham United in 18th having a game in hand.

The match itself saw Everton climb to fifth in the league standings, highlighting their strong performance which overshadowed the controversy surrounding Tarkowski’s actions. Several Everton players delivered standout performances, contributing to a comprehensive victory.

Next Steps for Nottingham Forest

As Nottingham Forest prepares to file their complaint, the club aims to address what they deem a critical oversight by match officials. This situation raises broader questions about officiating standards in the Premier League, particularly regarding VAR’s role in ensuring fair play.

The PGMOL has yet to respond to Nottingham Forest’s intended complaint, but the outcome could have implications for future officiating protocols. The club’s leadership is determined to pursue clarity on the matter, reflecting their commitment to ensuring that the integrity of the game is upheld.

In light of these developments, fans and analysts alike will be closely watching how both the PGMOL and the league address the concerns raised by Nottingham Forest in the coming days.